Comprehensive reviews and rankings of top auto insurers
Find the perfect insurance company for your needs with our detailed comparisons
Choosing the right car insurance company is about more than just finding the lowest price. The best insurers combine competitive rates, comprehensive coverage options, excellent customer service, and reliable claims handling. With over 100 auto insurance companies operating in the United States, finding the right one can be overwhelming.
Our comprehensive guide analyzes the top 10 car insurance companies based on market share, financial strength, customer satisfaction scores, coverage options, and real customer experiences. Whether you prioritize low rates, superior service, or innovative technology, this guide will help you find the best insurer for your needs.
State Farm
Market leader with excellent service
GEICO
Low rates with strong backing
USAA
Military families only
Progressive
Accepts most drivers
GEICO
Top-rated mobile app
Erie Insurance
12 states, great rates
Market Share
16.7%
AM Best Rating
A++
J.D. Power Score
872/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,506
Best For
Drivers who value personal service and stability
Multi-policy (up to 20%)
Multi-vehicle (up to 25%)
Good driving (up to 30%)
Good student (up to 25%)
Steer Clear (under 25 drivers)
Market Share
13.7%
AM Best Rating
A++
J.D. Power Score
868/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,193
Best For
Tech-savvy drivers seeking low rates
Military (up to 15%)
Federal employee (up to 12%)
Multi-policy (up to 25%)
Good driver (up to 26%)
Anti-theft devices (up to 25%)
Market Share
13.9%
AM Best Rating
A+
J.D. Power Score
859/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,342
Best For
High-risk drivers and comparison shoppers
Snapshot (up to 30%)
Multi-policy (average 5%)
Multi-car (average 12%)
Continuous coverage (average 10%)
Pay-in-full (average 5%)
Market Share
9.8%
AM Best Rating
A+
J.D. Power Score
856/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,628
Best For
Drivers wanting comprehensive coverage options
Drivewise (up to 40%)
Safe driver (up to 35%)
New car (up to 30%)
Multi-policy (up to 25%)
Early signing (10%)
Market Share
5.5%
AM Best Rating
A++
J.D. Power Score
891/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,176
Best For
Military members and their families
Safe driver (up to 20%)
Multi-vehicle (up to 12%)
Military installation (up to 15%)
Good student (up to 10%)
Driver training (up to 3%)
Market Share
5.1%
AM Best Rating
A
J.D. Power Score
845/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,783
Best For
Drivers with newer vehicles
RightTrack (up to 30%)
Multi-policy (up to 20%)
Multi-car (up to 25%)
New vehicle (up to 5%)
Good student (up to 22%)
Market Share
4.5%
AM Best Rating
A
J.D. Power Score
842/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,865
Best For
Drivers needing specialized coverage
Signal (up to 30%)
Multi-policy (up to 20%)
Good student (up to 25%)
Homeowner (up to 5%)
Business professional (up to 10%)
Market Share
3.9%
AM Best Rating
A+
J.D. Power Score
850/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,427
Best For
Long-term customers seeking loyalty benefits
SmartRide (up to 40%)
Multi-policy (up to 25%)
Good student (up to 15%)
Safe driver (up to 35%)
Anti-theft (up to 5%)
Market Share
2.1%
AM Best Rating
A
J.D. Power Score
847/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,389
Best For
Midwest drivers seeking regional expertise
KnowYourDrive (up to 20%)
Multi-policy (up to 29%)
Good student (up to 25%)
Defensive driver (up to 10%)
Loyalty (up to 10%)
Market Share
1.3%
AM Best Rating
A+
J.D. Power Score
869/1000
Avg. Annual Premium
$1,208
Best For
Drivers in covered states wanting stability
Multi-policy (up to 25%)
Multi-car (up to 35%)
Safe driver (up to 30%)
Youthful driver (up to 15%)
Life-long learning (up to 10%)
Financial Strength (25%)
AM Best ratings indicate ability to pay claims
Customer Satisfaction (25%)
J.D. Power scores and customer reviews
Coverage Options (20%)
Variety and flexibility of policies offered
Pricing & Value (20%)
Competitive rates and discount availability
Claims Process (10%)
Speed and fairness of claims handling
Our rankings are based on comprehensive analysis of multiple authoritative sources:
As independent agents, we work with multiple top-rated insurance companies to find you the best coverage at competitive prices. Let us do the comparison shopping for you.
Verify insurer financial strength before buying:
Check complaint ratios before choosing:
Tips for accurate comparisons:
Need help navigating your options? Our independent agents work with multiple top-rated companies to find your ideal coverage.
Get Expert GuidanceConsider factors beyond price: financial stability (AM Best ratings), customer satisfaction scores, coverage options, discount availability, and claims handling reputation. Match the company's strengths to your specific needs and preferences.
Not always. While some budget insurers offer good value, extremely low rates might indicate poor claims service or limited coverage. Check financial ratings and customer reviews. Companies like GEICO offer competitive rates with strong backing.
It depends on your preferences. Local agents (State Farm, Allstate) provide personalized service and support during claims. Online companies (GEICO, Progressive) often have lower rates and better digital tools but less personal interaction.
Very important. AM Best ratings indicate a company's ability to pay claims. Stick with companies rated A- or higher. An A++ rating (State Farm, GEICO, USAA) indicates superior financial strength and claims-paying ability.
Yes, you can switch anytime, even mid-policy. Most companies will refund unused premiums. However, avoid gaps in coverage and compare cancellation fees. The best time to switch is at renewal to avoid potential fees.