September 1, 202512 min readNatural Disasters

Hurricane Ida 4-Year Anniversary: Bergen County's $3.2 Billion Insurance Reality Check - Are You Still Underinsured?

September 1, 2025 marks 4 years since Hurricane Ida devastated Bergen County with $3.2 billion in damage. Critical insurance coverage review for all flood-prone areas.

September 1, 2021 - September 1, 2025

4 Years Since The Storm

23 lives lost. $3.2 billion in damage. Thousands still recovering.

45,000+

Homes Affected

96%

Uninsured for Floods

$60,800

Average Coverage Gap

September 1, 2025: Four Years Later

At 8:47 PM on September 1, 2021, the first 911 call came in from a Little Ferry basement. Within hours, Bergen County would face its worst natural disaster in modern history. Today, thousands of families are still recovering—and many more remain dangerously underinsured.

The Night Bergen County Will Never Forget

If you lived in Bergen County that night, you remember exactly where you were. The rain that started as a typical late-summer storm transformed into a biblical deluge—7 to 10 inches in just hours. The Hackensack River rose 10 feet. The Passaic River crested at levels not seen since Floyd in 1999.

Route 46 became a river. Route 17 in Paramus turned into a lake. Cars floated down Washington Avenue in Bergenfield like boats. In Maywood, Memorial Park became an inland sea. Cranford saw its downtown submerged for the third time in a decade.

The Human Toll

  • ⚰️23 lives lost in New Jersey—11 trapped in basement apartments
  • 🕯️Elizabeth: Four family members, including a 71-year-old and her son
  • 🕯️Passaic: A 70-year-old man in his car on Route 46
  • 🕯️Milford: Two friends swept away trying to escape their vehicles

$3.2 Billion: The Price Tag Bergen County Is Still Paying

Bergen County Damage

  • Total Damage: $3.2 billion
  • Homes Affected: 45,000+
  • Businesses Impacted: 2,800
  • Cars Totaled: 15,000+
  • FEMA Applications: 31,000

Hardest Hit Areas

  • Little Ferry: 800 homes flooded
  • Maywood: Entire neighborhoods underwater
  • Hackensack: River communities devastated
  • Rochelle Park: Passaic River overflow
  • Lodi: Saddle River flooding

The Insurance Gap Reality:

Only 4% of Bergen County homeowners had flood insurance when Ida hit. The average claim? $68,000. The average FEMA grant? $7,200. That's a $60,800 gap that destroyed savings, retirement funds, and futures. Learn more about Bergen County's flood insurance crisis.

Four Years Later: The Battles Continue

The Maywood Family Still in Limbo

"We're still fighting with our insurance company. They paid for the initial cleanup but claim the foundation damage was 'pre-existing.' We've spent $45,000 on lawyers and engineers. Our kids ask when we can go home. We don't have an answer."

— Anonymous resident, West Pleasant Avenue

The Little Ferry Business Owner

"Insurance covered the equipment but not the six months we were closed. We nearly lost everything. Now we pay $18,000 a year for flood insurance—if we can keep it. FEMA keeps threatening to change our zone classification."

— Restaurant owner, Main Street

The Hackensack Retiree

"We thought we were covered. Turns out, 'ground water' isn't covered unless you have flood insurance. $120,000 in damage. We took a reverse mortgage just to rebuild. At 73, I'm back to having a mortgage."

— Riverside neighborhood resident

The 2025 Reality: Why You're More Underinsured Than Ever

The Inflation Gap Crisis

Construction Costs: Up 42% Since 2021

That $400,000 rebuild in 2021? It's $568,000 today. If your coverage hasn't increased by at least 40%, you're underinsured.

Labor Shortage: 6-Month Wait Times

Bergen County has lost 30% of its skilled contractors since COVID. Emergency repairs that took days now take weeks. Costs have tripled.

Material Costs: Still Climbing

  • Lumber: +65% since 2021
  • Concrete: +48% since 2021
  • Electrical components: +82% since 2021
  • Roofing materials: +55% since 2021

FEMA's 2025 Flood Map Changes

This October, FEMA releases new flood maps. Preliminary data shows:

  • 18,000 more Bergen homes entering high-risk zones
  • Fort Lee to Edgewater: Entire corridor now "Special Hazard"
  • Hackensack River towns: Mandatory insurance zones expanding
  • Average premium increase: $2,400 to $4,100 annually

Your Labor Day Weekend Insurance Action Plan

This Weekend: 7 Critical Steps

1

Document Everything NOW

Video every room, open every drawer, capture serial numbers. Upload to cloud storage. This weekend, before hurricane season peaks.

Estimated time: 2 hours
2

Check Your Coverage Limits

Pull out your policy. If your dwelling coverage is the same as 2021, you're underinsured by at least 40%. Call your agent Tuesday.

Estimated time: 30 minutes
3

Understand Your Deductibles

Hurricane deductibles are different—usually 2-5% of dwelling coverage. On a $500,000 home, that's $10,000-$25,000 out of pocket.

Critical to understand before disaster
4

GET FLOOD INSURANCE NOW

30-day waiting period. Peak hurricane season is September-October. If you buy Tuesday, you're covered by October 2nd. Wait another week? You're gambling with your future.

URGENT: Only 4% of Bergen County has flood insurance

5

Review Additional Living Expenses

Bergen County hotel: $200/night minimum. Restaurant meals for a family: $150/day. Six months displaced? That's $45,000. Is that your ALE limit?

Average displacement: 4-6 months
6

Create Your Emergency Fund

Insurance doesn't pay immediately. You need $10,000 minimum accessible within 24 hours for emergency repairs, temporary housing, and deductibles.

Set up separate savings account today
7

Know Your Contractors NOW

After Ida, legitimate contractors were booked for months. Scammers appeared overnight. Get three verified contractors' numbers this weekend.

Save contacts in your phone today

Your Bergen County Neighborhood: Know Your Risk

Extreme Risk Areas

  • Little Ferry: Mehrhof Pond area
  • Moonachie: Entire borough
  • Lodi: Saddle River zones
  • Maywood: Memorial Park vicinity
  • Rochelle Park: Passaic River bend
  • Hackensack: Riverside neighborhoods

High Risk Areas

  • Paramus: Sprout Brook areas
  • River Edge: Hackensack River zones
  • New Milford: Low-lying areas
  • Bogota: Near water treatment
  • Teaneck: Overpeck Creek
  • Ridgefield Park: Overpeck areas

The "We Never Flooded Before" Zones

Ida proved nowhere is safe. These areas saw first-time flooding:

  • Fort Lee (Palisades base)
  • Englewood (East Hill)
  • • Tenafly (Downtown)
  • Cresskill (Camp Merritt)
  • • Demarest (Northern sections)
  • • Haworth (Valley areas)

What Insurance Companies Don't Want You to Know

The Coverage Gaps That Destroyed Lives

Sewer Backup ≠ Flood Coverage

Most Bergen County Ida damage came from sewer backup. Standard policies cap this at $10,000. Actual damage averaged $75,000.

"Ground Water" Exclusion

Water that enters through foundation cracks isn't covered without flood insurance—even if your neighbor's pool collapsed into your basement.

The 72-Hour Rule

Multiple storms within 72 hours? That's multiple deductibles. Ida was preceded by Henri. Many paid double deductibles.

Contents Coverage Percentage

Your contents aren't covered at replacement cost unless specified. That $3,000 TV? Insurance values it at $400 "actual cash value."

September 2025: This Time, We're Ready

Four years ago, Bergen County learned the hardest lesson possible: Mother Nature doesn't care about flood zone maps, hundred-year storms now happen every decade, and being "fully insured" doesn't mean what we thought it meant.

But here's what's different now: We know. We've seen our neighbors lose everything. We've watched families torn apart by financial devastation that followed the flood waters. We've learned that "it won't happen here" is the most expensive lie we can tell ourselves.

Bergen County Strong: What We've Built

  • Municipal Warning Systems: Every town now has emergency alerts
  • Pump Stations: $180 million in upgrades across the county
  • Building Codes: New elevation requirements in flood zones
  • Community Response: Neighbor helping neighbor networks
  • Insurance Awareness: Flood insurance purchases up 400%

The Choice: Three Months of Premiums or Three Years of Recovery?

The average Bergen County family that was properly insured—including flood coverage—paid about $6,000 annually in total premiums. They received average claims payments of $285,000.

The average uninsured family? They're still paying off $150,000 in loans, their kids' college funds are gone, and they're one storm away from bankruptcy.

Which family do you want to be when the next Ida hits?

Don't Let History Repeat Itself

This Labor Day weekend, while others are barbecuing, take 2 hours to protect everything you've worked for. Because when the next storm hits—and it will—you'll either be acautionary tale or a success story.

Available 7 days a week through Labor Day weekend. Bergen County specialists standing by.

To every Bergen County family still rebuilding: We see you. We're here for you.

To everyone else: Don't wait for your Ida story. The forecast is already forming somewhere over the Atlantic. The question isn't if, but when.

September 1, 2021, changed Bergen County forever.

What you do this weekend determines whether you're ready for what's coming.

Critical Resources

Emergency Contacts

  • • Bergen County OEM: (201) 336-6000
  • • FEMA Disaster Help: 1-800-621-3362
  • • Red Cross: 1-800-RED-CROSS
  • • NJ 211 (Resources): Dial 211

This article is dedicated to the 23 New Jersey residents who lost their lives in Hurricane Ida, and to the thousands of Bergen County families still rebuilding. Your strength inspires us every day.

About Midland Insurance: Serving Bergen County since 2019, we've been here through every storm. We helped hundreds of families navigate Ida claims, and we're committed to ensuring no family faces the next storm unprotected.

Need Construction Insurance?

Get expert advice and competitive quotes from Bergen County's construction insurance specialists.